I want to be a force for real good

John Coltrane and the Force for real good.
Talk for the Coltrane Home Student day – Nov 14, 2026
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

“I want to be a force for real good. In other words. I know that there are bad forces, forces that bring suffering to others and misery to the world, but I want to be the opposite force. I want to be the force which is truly for good”.
John Coltrane
Today on this special occasion we celebrate the music, the life, and the spirit of John Coltrane– It is truly a joy to hear his music being played by young musicians today, sounds that would no doubt fill Mr. Coltrane’s heart with a great joy.
We all know about John Coltrane, the dedicated, virtuoso, genius saxophonist who pushed the limits of what his instrument could do and expanded the directions the music could go in. In his brief lifespan he was able to make a huge impact on the jazz community and audiences beyond jazz in ways that I’m not sure he even would have imagined himself. But today, I want to focus on the impact that he wanted to make on the world, as witnessed by the words that I read to start this talk.
In this well-known quote, Mr. Coltrane didn’t say that he wanted to be the best saxophonist, the most famous, the most popular, the one with the most followers on social media…… Rather he states here that he wants to be a “Force for real good”, and an antidote to the forces that bring suffering and misery to the world. That’s a big aspiration-John Coltrane was a big aspirational thinker.
But let’s be honest here ----- Do you think that music can actually make that kind of impact on the world?? I know that I believe music can bring joy to listeners, create moments of happiness and distract from what Art Blakey referred to as the “dust of everyday life”. But can music feed a hungry child? Can music reduce social injustice in this world? Can music stop a war??
I am here today to tell you…..that I believe it can.
Before you tell me that you think I’m crazy, I’ll share that I’m kind of kidding here, except that I’m not. In Trane’s well known “Force for Good” quote he uses language about suffering and misery in the world that lets me know, as a former religious studies major in college, that he had been reading from lots of sources in world religions – but especially in the Buddhist traditions (Trane was always seeking out a lot of spiritual texts and sources for inspiration). In the Buddhist tradition there is a concept of the “Eightfold Path” or Eight ways of acting in this world that bring joy and reduce suffering for yourself and those around you. One of those eight ways is the concept of Samyak Karmanta – roughly translating as “Right Action”.
One of those right actions, for you and for me, is playing music and sharing music. Music is created when vibrations (from a saxophone, or a drum) are shared in the world from the creator to the receiver and those vibrations can have a tangible positive impact in many ways from physical, to emotional, but also even social and cultural – at times perhaps even political. So, when we share a sound with a tenor saxophone, I believe it’s important to be mindful of the impact we are having on the world around us, beyond just if we are playing well, or if the music sounds good.
How can we create sounds that have that kind of positive impact in the world? It may sound a little crazy, but I believe it’s through the intention we have when we make the sound – and like anything else intention can be practiced! Try playing some long tones next time you practice and set a definite intention for those sounds – to make your friend who is sad feel cared for, to help a family in need get some assistance, to provide comfort to a child. This is serious stuff - as Mr. Coltrane said, “a force for real good”, to be the opposite of the forces that bring about suffering and misery in the world. You can do it, but it takes practice – in fact, it IS a practice and if you do it every day you will see the results, not only in you but in those around you.
Here's another quote from John Coltrane:“I think that music, being an expression of the human heart, or of the human being itself, does express just what is happening - the whole of human experience at the particular time that it is being expressed”
John Coltrane
As music students we are often encouraged by our teachers to work hard to “sound our best” – one of the beautiful things about jazz music is that we sound our best when we are being the most like ourselves, the most honest, the most complete version of ourselves. Of course we want to sound “good”- technically proficient, well versed in the history and “language” of the jazz masters that we idolize (and John Coltrane himself was a famously dedicated practicer from early on to achieve these goals). But really it is, according to John Coltrane, “the whole of human experience at the particular time that it is being expressed” that is what we should be ultimately striving for. Even the greatest saxophonist who ever lived, John Coltrane, knew that and I think he would be most happy hearing young musicians who are striving to sound the most like themselves in that moment.
“In any situation that we find in our lives, when there is something that we feel should be better, we must exert effort to try and make it better. So it's the same socially, musically, politically in any department of our lives”
John ColtraneSocially, Musically, politically – It’s amazing that Mr. Coltrane brings all these big concepts into his perspective on making music. Again, we are finding through Trane’s quotes here that his biggest thoughts on music making have to do with the impact that music can have. Yes, the impact on the individual - but also on the community around us, and even on the larger units of humanity- socially, politically and spiritually. I love that he uses the word “Effort” here, as this tells us once again that it is the intention that matters most, not the result. In fact, another of the Buddhist “Eightfold Path” is Samyak Pradhana, or “Right Effort” which states that this effort should not be just the individual striving for personal greatness but that it should have “joy and ease” and be a natural part of living life from a joyful and hopeful perspective. In any situation, Mr. Coltrane believes we should exert effort, but I believe that it is effort in a self-affirming way that shares joy and positivity without self judgement or fear that produces the greatest results.
“I think music is an instrument. It can create the initial thought patterns, that can create the changes in the thinking of the people”.
John Coltrane
Thought patterns – When we practice music, we are training our bodies to respond in particular ways to create the sounds we want to create – muscle memory. But we are also training our minds to embrace sound, to share sound, to use sound to impact the world in particular ways. Turning once again to the Buddhist principles of the Eightfold Path, there is one called Samyak Samkalpa, “Right Resolve”.
This principle speaks to the idea of creating positive thought patterns, which is an essential part of musical practice as much as developing “chops”, finger strength and speed and endurance. I think we can view Coltrane’s own journey in his astounding and continual development as an artist as an intentional attempt to bring his own consciousness more and more into peace, liberation and joy in the present moment, which is a good way of understanding the increasingly abstract and spontaneous nature of his improvisations in the later work.
I would like to read you one last quote from Mr. Coltrane that kind of sums up some of these ideas we have talked about:
“I think the majority of musicians are interested in truth --- they’ve got to be because a musical thing is a truth. If you play and make a statement, a musical statement, and it’s a valid statement, that’s a truth right there in itself. If you play something phony you know that’s phony. All musicians are striving to get as near to perfection as they can get. That’s truth. So in order to play those kind of things, to play truth, you’ve got to live with as much truth as you possibly can”
John Coltrane
Truth ---- no that’s a challenging concept today, maybe it always has been a tough one, but in our age where information comes to us from all angles, mostly through our phones, and generated by both human and ai sources, it’s a real challenge to know what is true. Knowing what it true is more elusive, and important than ever, and I believe it will be the biggest challenge for young people coming up in the world today – truth.
So, today I have tried to take John Coltrane’s own words in conversation with journalists and draw out the path that he laid out for us, from intention to truth to action – and in doing so I have used some of the ideas of the Buddhist Eightfold Path to reflect on some of these ideas as well; And for me there is a great alignment between the two – the idea that music making in its best form is – a force for real good.
To close out today I want to encourage you to think about your own music practice – your own practice sessions but also your overall practice as a musician because musicians have a practice just like doctor, a dentist or a lawyer. I hope you are encouraged that you are on a path to be a real force for good in this world. Take these words and ideas of John Coltrane with you and move forward on that path with right effort, action, and resolve and we will all benefit greatly from your good work.




Comments